How Much Is a Mile Worth? Value of American AAdvantage Miles
Avatar_160_hilary
Hilary Stockton
Google+

My Award Booking Service helps travelers book first class and business class with miles and points. As an independent affiliate of Cadence, I also have access to Virtuoso, Four Seasons Preferred Partner, Peninsula Hotels PenClub, Dorchester Diamond Club, Ritz-Carlton STARS, Starwood Luxury Privileges, Rocco Forte and other 5-star hotel partners, so I can book, for no extra cost, your perfect luxury hotel or luxury cruise with VIP amenities not available anywhere else. Become a client and upgrade your stay!

GOT A BLOG POST IDEA?
Have a travel question we haven't covered yet? Want to share your secrets for traveling well for less?

How Much Is a Mile Worth? Value of American AAdvantage Miles

 

What is an American AAdvantage mile worth? This is the second in our What is a Mile Worth series; for the introduction and valuation of a United MileagePlus mile, see How Much Is A Mile Worth? Value of United Airlines Miles.

As we wrote in our intro post, there is no one single valuation when it comes to what a mile or point is worth, unless you're talking about a specific award ticket and only looking at the nominal value, which is what the actual retail price is less award fees, and divide that by the miles required to book the award + the miles you would have earned on a paid ticket.

The reason why what a mile is worth can vary so much is because of these factors:

  • Personal Value of the Trip: If you earn $1 Million a year, you're likely to be willing to pay much more for a first class ticket than if you make $100,000 a year. Or, if this trip is your honeymoon, again, you're likely to be willing to pay much more vs. a more impulsive value-oriented trip. 
  • Trip Itinerary: Most long haul international award travel will give you much more value than domestic trips will. That's also why so many Americans don't see the value of collecting frequent flyer miles--most of their trips are within the U.S., or are package deals to Mexico or the Caribbean.
  • Class of Travel: Just as with trip itinerary, value varies enormously depending on whether you're redeeming for economy, business class or first class. The greatest value will generally come from international first class.
  • Airline: Most folks will agree that flying Cathay Pacific first class is a lot nicer than flying American first class, so that also figures into the valuation.
Given these factors, to figure out how much an American AAdvantage mile is worth to you, I'd pick 2-3 trips that you hope to actually book using your American AAdvantage miles and base your valuation on that. Here are my examples, which will lead to my own personal valuation of American AAdvantage miles, though this may or may not be yours.
 
Example 1: Cathay Pacific First Class and Business Class NYC to Bali via Hong Kong

My family and I flew Cathay Pacific first class and business class to Bali via Hong Kong this past summer, and we may well do another trip to Asia on Cathay Pacific in the coming years, so this is a good proxy for us. It's easier for us to take a major trip in late summer, so that's when I'd check the revenue fares for. Note that only the NYC-Hong Kong portion is first class; Hong Kong to Bali is 2-class service (business class and economy) although traveling on a first class award, you may just be lucky enough to be seated in one of the first class seats, with business class service. See my Cathay Pacific First Class Bali to Hong Kong Review.
 
How Much is A Mile Worth? Value of American AAdvantage Mile - Cathay First Class to Bali
 
 
As you can see, the nominal value is very high: revenue ticket prices for first class on Cathay (and even American) are over $26,000. Even after accounting for a few hundred dollars in award fees and the miles you would have earned crediting a Cathay first class revenue ticket to American (~30,600 miles, based on 1.5x due to first class cabin bonus) you'd still have a nominal value of 15.7 cents per American AAdvantage mile.
 
Now, my family, and most others, would never pay over $26,000 per person to fly first class. But for a special trip, we would pay about $3500 for such a ticket. That leads me to a subjective value of 1.9 cents per American AAdvantage mile in this example.
 


Example 2: Etihad First Class and Business Class NYC to the Maldives via Abu Dhabi

This is a trip we plan to take, since we love snorkeling and diving. Etihad is a not in oneworld but is an American AAdvantage partner; see Use American Airlines miles for Etihad First Class.

How Much is an American AAdvantage Mile Worth? Etihad First Class to Abu Dhabi

How Much is an AAdvantage Mile Worth? Etihad Business Class Abu Dhabi to Maldives

 

Here, the nominal value of about 8 cents per American AAdvantage mile is about half that of the Cathay Pacific example, since the NYC-Abu Dhabi first class flight, while just a couple hours less than NYC-Hong Kong, is a lot cheaper, at less than $15,000. Note that Abu Dhabi to Male, Maldives is only 2-class, business class and economy. 

Given the similar amount of flight time to the Bali trip, we'd also pay about $3500 for first class to Abu Dhabi and business class to the Maldives, so my subjective value is 1.6 cents per American AAdvantage mile for us in this example.


Earning American AAdvantage Miles

If you have available a fair amount of money that is otherwise just earning low rates of interest, put that in a BankDirect checking account to earn a good chunk of American AAdvantage miles every month. Or if you want it upfront and don't mind not withdrawing it for a year or two, take out a BankDirect CD. Feel free to request a referral from me at concierge [at] travelsort.com, and we'll each earn an extra 1000 AAdvantage miles.

Another option is to open a Fidelity brokerage account, for up to 50,000 AA miles if you deposit $100,000. Keep in mind that if you or your spouse works at a financial institution (anything affiliated with FINRA or a securities exchange) you're not eligible for the Fidelity offer. I recommend taking advantage of BankDirect instead.

If you don't have money that can put at BankDirect or Fidelity, then focus on Citi AAdvantage credit cards. You can apply for two personal simultaneously to earn 90,000 AA miles, then later apply for the CitiBusiness AAdvantage card for another 50,000 AA miles. See current application links on either Best Travel Credit Cards or Earn 1 Million Miles and Points a Year Without Flying.

Don't forget to apply for other miles and points credit cards at the same time. Why? Because if you apply for several cards together (as close in time as possible) issuers won't see that you've had a lot of recent inquiries and are more likely to approve you, assuming of course a good credit score. And diversity of miles and points is important too, both to give you flexibility when constructing your award trips and to hedge against devaluations in any one program.

 

How Much American AAdvantage Miles Are Worth to Me

If I average out the values of the two above examples, that gives me 1.75 cents per American AAdvantage mile. That said, I'd also want to take into account how American AAdvantage miles in these types of trips are easier for my family to use when planning ahead and wanting to secure a couple of first class awards and a business class award all on the same flight. It's harder, for example, with Lufthansa since Lufthansa first class can only be booked up to 15 days in advance with United miles.

Plus, as we wrote in Maximizing the Value of Your Award Ticket with Stopovers and Open Jaws, you can get a free one way on American, albeit only out of one of American's hub cities (Dallas Fort Worth, Miami, Chicago, New York JFK, Los Angeles LAX). You can also use American's oneworld award chart to construct some pretty creative itineraries, although traveling with a young kid, we won't be taking advantage of that until he's older.

On the negative side, you can't have international stopovers on American partner awards, and American's routing rules limit how much you can leverage middle east carriers such as Etihad (and Qatar, which is joining oneworld) since getting to Europe or Asia would require a separate award.

Nonetheless,  the convenience of advance award availability on such stellar partners pushes my valuation slightly above the higher end of the range of the above examples: my valuation is 2 cents per American AAdvantage mile.

Again, that doesn't mean I'd buy an American AAdvantage mile at 2 cents each, because via BankDirect I can earn AAdvantage Miles for Half a Cent per Mile. But you'd need to pay me 2 cents per American AAdvantage mile for me to sell them, and more than that if I was just about to redeem them for a family trip.

How much is an American AAdvantage mile worth to you?

Related Posts:
 
How Much Is A Mile Worth? Value of United Airlines Miles
 
 
 
 

Need Award Booking Help? Our fee is as low as $75 per ticket if you book your hotel through us.

If you enjoyed this, join 200,000+ readers: please follow TravelSort on Twitter or  like us on Facebook to be alerted to new posts. 

Become a TravelSort Client and Book Your Hotel with Virtuoso or Four Seasons Preferred VIP Amenities!

 
Disclosure: I have a BankDirect Mileage Checking Account, but I have no other connection to BankDirect and have not been compensated to write this post. 
  • |
  • Print
    print |
Related Articles
Square_tipping_guide_for_nyc
8/26/2015
  How Much to Tip in NYC? TravelSort reader Louise writes "As an Australian, tipping is not something we're used to, but I do understand that it's expected in the U.S.  My family and I will be visiting NYC in...
Square_review-sofitel_vienna_stephansdom-the_loft_restaurant-ceiling
8/25/2015
  This Sofitel Vienna Stephansdom Review is part of a trip report including Vienna and Moscow and St. Petersburg in Russia. Our Vienna stay transpired because it was a convenient overnight from Florence (see our reviews of the Four Seasons...
Comments
Leave a Comment
Comment
Facebook-logo
Get Free Email Blog Updates
Popular Articles
Square_review-singapore_suites_a380-suite_1a
7/11/2015
  This review of Singapore Suites A380 New York JFK to Frankfurt, with a kid, is part of a trip report featuring Singapore Suites, Air Berlin Business Class, and luxury hotel stays, dining and activities in Berlin and Italy.  For...
Square_eu_compensation_for_united_airlines_flight_971_stranded_in_belfast
6/25/2015
  Is United liable for EC 261/2004 compensation for United Flight 971 from Rome to Chicago, which diverted to Belfast over an unruly passenger and stranded passengers in Belfast Airport for over 20 hours? TravelSort reader Dawn writes: "I was...
Square_tips-_packing_light_for_a_month
7/2/2015
  I’m a big believer in never checking luggage and bringing only carry-on bags, but how does this work for a month or more of travel? A few of my clients asked for a post on packing light, and how...
Square_10_tips_to_travel_better_with_kids
7/5/2015
  How to travel better with kids? Some couples, childless or parents, would say they'd rather not travel with kids at all. But really, who wasn't a kid once? And aren't some of your most memorable experiences trips that you...
Square_travel_checklist-_what_to_do_before_your_trip
6/23/2015
Travel checklists--love them or hate them, they can be handy in terms of checking that you have everything you need before you take your trip or go on vacation. Here's what I recommend for clients, and I'm sure savvy readers...
Square_four_seasons_residential_vacation_rentals_with_preferred_partner_benefits
6/16/2015
Four Seasons Residential Rentals with Four Seasons Preferred Partner benefits combine the best of both worlds: a luxury vacation home, but with complimentary breakfast (no dish washing!), daily housekeeping and turndown service, and access to all the amenities of the...
Square_pompeii_photos-private_tour-amphitheater
7/21/2015
  This Private Tours of Pompeii Review and Photos post is part of a trip report featuring Singapore Suites, Air Berlin Business Class, and luxury hotel stays, dining and activities in Berlin and Italy.  For the prior posts, please see: Review: Air...
Square_paestum_greek_temple_to_hera_and_poseidon
7/26/2015
  These Paestum Greek temple photos are part of a trip report featuring the Amalfi Coast, Tuscany, Florence, Rome, Singapore Suites, Air Berlin Business Class, and luxury hotel stays, dining and activities in Berlin and Italy.  For the prior posts,...
Square_delta_lounge_access_for_guests-delta_sky_club
8/6/2015
  What is Delta's Lounge Access Policy for Guests and Kids? And when using an AMEX Platinum, what's the best strategy for gaining access for a spouse and kids? TravelSort reader Diana writes "Do you have a suggestion for getting...
Square_review-four_seasons_firenze-florence-view_of_duomo_cathedral_from_gardens
8/16/2015
This Review of Four Seasons Firenze Hotel in Florence, Italy is part of a trip report featuring Florence, Rome, Amalfi Coast, Tuscany, Singapore Suites, Air Berlin Business Class, and luxury hotel stays, dining and activities in Berlin and Italy.  For the prior...