Best Premium Economy Airline Seats

As I wrote about in late 2010, we’re seeing a changing landscape in the airline industry whereby airlines are eliminating first class and instead adding a premium economy product. With the recession and continuously improving business class products, how could any executive justify first class nowadays, given that many airlines have flat bed business class products? We’re seeing this trend right now with Cathay Pacific and Qantas, whereby just about all of their new aircraft are three cabin planes with coach, premium economy, and business class.

With that in mind, I figured it would make sense to compare the top premium economy products as far as comfort goes. Unfortunately I don’t get to fly premium economy all that much, since most US airlines don’t have an award chart for premium economy on their partner airlines, while it’s often possible to redeem miles for premium economy if booking through the airline operating the flight directly.

It’s also worth noting that several US airlines have an “economy plus” product, though that’s a bit different than premium economy. Premium economy is typically found on longhaul flights and similar to domestic first class, often with added services, like premium check-in and/or an enhanced food selection. The “economy plus” products found on US airlines, on the other hand, typically only feature a bit of extra legroom. Presently United offers Economy Plus on all of their aircraft, while Delta offers “Economy Comfort” on much of their longhaul fleet, and will soon be expanding it to their domestic fleet. American has also announced that they’ll be installing a section with extra legroom on their new 777-300ER aircraft, which they’ll be taking delivery of later this year.

While premium economy fares vary greatly based on the route and airline, I’d say as a general rule they’re about twice as much as coach fares and half as much as business class fares.

One last thing worth noting is that many airlines with a premium economy product will only let you upgrade a single cabin with miles, meaning if you pay for economy you can only upgrade to premium economy, so you need to pay for premium economy in order to upgrade to business class. Keep that in mind if you’re trying to upgrade, because with US airlines we’re often used to being able to upgrade to business class on standard coach tickets.

 

Qantas Premium Economy

Qantas is focusing heavily on the premium economy market as they cut first class out of much of their fleet in lieu of a larger premium economy cabin, where they seem to be see more potential. They have the standard reclining seat, though offer premium economy passengers better food and priority check-in.

Qantas Frequent Flyers can redeem their points for premium economy at a 50% premium over economy.

Cathay Pacific Premium Economy

Despite the fact that Cathay Pacific just recently started introducing a premium economy product, it’s in no way a cutting edge design, but rather just a traditional reclining premium economy product. Since the product is so new, a lot remains to be seen, including how much they’ll be charging for the product in miles.

 

Air New Zealand Premium Economy

Air New Zealand has a pretty unique premium economy product, especially on their 777-300ER aircraft. It’s in a 2-2-2 configuration, with seats angled towards the side of the aircraft. Unlike premium economy on other airlines, which is more like domestic first class, Air New Zealand’s premium economy comes in the form of a shell seat with a lot more privacy than most of the competition offers.

As a result of the seat design, some complain that it feels a bit confined, given how much privacy there is with somewhat limited space. Also, as a result of the seat design, legroom is somewhat constrained, since you can only slide your feet so far underneath the seat in front of you.

Air New Zealand lets you redeem Airpoints for premium economy awards, typically at about a 50% premium over economy.

British Airways World Traveler Plus

British Airways has among the more “traditional” premium economy products with their World Traveler Plus cabin, which features roughly 38” of pitch and 18.5” of width. On the 777 and 747, World Traveler Plus is in a 2-4-2 configuration (as opposed to 3-3-3 in coach on the 777 and 3-4-3 in coach on the 747), while on the 767 it’s in a 2-2-2 configuration (as opposed to 2-3-2 in coach).

The seat gets pretty good reviews for comfort and sleeping given that the recline is fairly decent. The issue is that when the person in front of you reclines space is very limited, as the seat is really designed to maximize sleep. This is one benefit of Air New Zealand’s new premium economy seat, where you can’t in any way encroach on the space of the person behind you, given that it’s a shell seat.

You can redeem British Airways Avios points for World Traveler Plus at a premium of 50% over World Traveler.

 

Virgin Atlantic Premium Economy

Virgin Atlantic more or less pioneered premium economy, and their product hasn’t changed all that much over the years. The seat itself is very similar to British Airways’, in a 2-4-2 configuration in a 2-3-2 configuration on the A340 and 2-4-2 configuration on the 747, though the seat does have a couple of extra inches of width. Much like with British Airways, personal space can be very limited when the person in front of you reclines, so being in premium economy is probably more useful on a flight where you want to sleep, as opposed to a daytime flight.

You can redeem Virgin Atlantic Flying Club miles for Premium Economy at a premium of roughly 50% over economy.

 

Air France Premium Voyageur Class (Airbus 380)

While Air France’s Premium Voyageur Class is a pretty standard premium economy product in the rest of their fleet, on the Airbus 380 they have up to 49” of pitch, which is industry-leading for a premium economy product. It’s worth noting that Air France has two versions of the Airbus 380, and only one version features a Premium Voyageur Class, so be sure to look out for that when making a reservation.

This seat really is the best of both worlds, given that it not only has excellent recline, but is also a shell seat, meaning you won’t be uncomfortable if the person in front of you reclines.

Air France Flying Blue miles can be redeemed for Premium Voyageur Class, for an approximately 50% premium over economy.

I suspect that over the coming years we’ll see premium economy become more relevant for those of us in the US, not just because the product is constantly getting more popular, but also because I suspect it will eventually be introduced as a mileage redemption option for US frequent flyer programs.

In a few years I suspect we’ll see a lot more airlines with premium economy cabins than first class cabins, so it will be a serious consideration when booking a flight.

Have you flown premium economy yet? If so, on which airline and how was your experience?

Airline

Seat pitch

Seat width

Food

Check-in

Qantas

38”

19.5”

Quality between economy and business

Premium Economy Check-in

Cathay Pacific

38”

18.5”

Quality between economy and business

Premium Economy Check-in

Air New Zealand 777-200ER (772)

39”

17.8”

Quality between economy and business

Premium Economy Check-in

Air New Zealand

747-400 (744)

38-40”

18.5”

Quality between economy and business

Premium Economy Check-in

British Airways (747, 777)

38”

18.5”

Quality between economy and business

No World Traveller Plus Check-in; only World Traveller (Economy)

Virgin Atlantic (Airbus A340)

38”

21”

Quality between economy and business; not quite as good as Qantas

Premium Economy Check-in

Air France

Airbus A380-800 – Version 2

49.8”

26.6”

Same as Economy

Premium Economy Check-in


Related Posts

United Economy Plus Upgrade Tips

The Changing Airline Industry Landscape: Hello Premium Economy, Bye-Bye First Class

Virgin America Main Cabin Select Review

Need Award Booking Help? Our fee is as low as $75 per ticket if you book your hotel through us.

If you enjoyed this, join 200,000+ readers: please follow TravelSort on Twitter or  like us on Facebook to be alerted to new posts. 

Become a TravelSort Client and Book 5-Star Hotels with Virtuoso or Four Seasons Preferred Partner Amenities! 

  • |
  • Print
    print |
Related Articles
Square_php8mx0efpm
3/13/2012
Last July I wrote a post about the 10 Best Premium Cabin Award Redemption Values. It’s amazing how quickly the industry changes, since I think the list could already use an update. This is due to program devaluations, changes in...
Square_php8mx0efpm
3/6/2012
March 3, 2012, marked the system integration of United and Continental Airlines. Many feared it would be a near meltdown given the massive scale of merging two airlines that ran on completely different systems. For the most part the transition...
Comments
Picture?type=large Jeffrey K. commented 22 Feb 2012
What about TK comfort class?
User_avatar_default Jamison N. commented 23 Feb 2012
what about KLM's economy comfort?
Picture?type=large Ben Schlappig commented 23 Feb 2012
@ Jeffrey -- They're another airline with a fairly good premium economy product, though from what I've heard it's not *that* great, and probably not that practical for many people to fly. @ Jamison -- KLM's Economy Comfort isn't really a premium economy product, but rather more of an economy plus product. It features extra legroom though not extra seat width or added services.
Leave a Comment
Comment
Facebook-logo
Get Free Email Blog Updates
Popular Articles
Square_how_we_earned_1_million_miles_and_points_in_2015_without_flying
12/29/2015
We earned about 1 frequent flyer million miles and points in 2015, without flying. Those last two words are key, because there are of course many travelers who earn far more than 1 million frequent flyer miles and points per...
Square_60k_citi_aadvantage_platinum_select_bonus_offer
11/13/2015
  A 60K Citi AAdvantage Platinum Select MasterCard offer is targeted to some AAdvantage members, as a special seasonal offer. Here's the offer my son received, even though we can't of course sign him up for it (though he was...
Square_review-american_airlines_767_business_class-bed_with_duvet_and_pillow
11/25/2015
  This American 767-300 Business Class review for a flight to Europe from NYC JFK is part of a trip report. For the prior post, please see Review: American Airlines Admirals Club Lounge JFK Terminal 8. While this wasn't an aspirational...
Square_review-etihad_a380_first_class_apartment-seat_2c
12/19/2015
  This Review of Etihad Airways A380 First Class Apartment is part of my husband's travel to Australia. See his prior post on the Etihad Premium Lounge in Abu Dhabi for Etihad First Class and Business Class passengers.   Etihad...
Square_review-emirates_first_class_a380-shower
12/8/2015
  This Emirates First Class A380 review of a New York JFK to Dubai flight is part of a new trip report featuring Qantas First Class on the A380 to Melbourne, Etihad First Apartment on the A380, and stays and fine...
Square_review-qantas_first_class_a380-seat_2a_window
12/10/2015
  This new Qantas First Class A380 review of a London to Dubai flight is part of a new trip report featuring Emirates A380 First Class, Etihad First Apartment on the A380, and stays and fine dining in some of New Zealand's...
Square_marriott_acquires_starwood-4_reasons_to_be_pessimistic-infographic
11/16/2015
Marriott will acquire Starwood Hotels & Resorts, per the SPG and Marriott press releases today. If approved, the merger would close in mid-2016 The focus is on the scale of the combined entity, which would be the largest hotel company...
Square_will_opening_new_credit_cards_hurt_your_credit_score
11/20/2015
Will opening and closing credit cards hurt your credit score? TravelSort reader Daniel comments on the Best Travel Credit Cards page: "Lots of great insight here, thanks! I'm worried about hurting my credit score. For example, if I open the...
Square_review-qantas_a380_first_class_dubai_to_melbourne-first_class_bed_after_turndown_service
12/14/2015
  This Qantas A380 First Class Dubai to Melbourne review is a continuation of our Qantas First Class London to Dubai flight. Since I covered the first class cabin and seats, seat selection, pajamas and amenity kit in my prior...
Square_which_new_travel_credit_cards_we_plan_to_apply_for
1/13/2016
  Which New Travel Credit Cards Do We Plan to Apply for in 2016? I'm getting ready to apply for a few new credit cards, although it will probably take a couple weeks until I get around to it due...