Capital One Venture Card: 5 Reasons It Isn't Worth It
Rewards Credit Cards
Hilary Stockton

My Award Booking Service helps travelers book first class and business class with miles and points. As an independent affiliate of Cadence, I also have access to Four Seasons Preferred Partner, VirtuosoPeninsula Hotels PenClub, Dorchester Diamond Club, Belmond Bellini Club, Shangri-La Luxury Circle, Langham CoutureRitz-Carlton STARS, Starwood Luxury Privileges, Rocco Forte and other 5-star hotel partners, so I can book, for no extra cost, your perfect luxury hotel or luxury cruise with VIP amenities not available anywhere else. Become a client and upgrade your stay!

Have a travel question we haven't covered yet? Want to share your secrets for traveling well for less?

Capital One Venture Card: 5 Reasons It Isn't Worth It

The Capital One Venture Rewards Card isn't worth it for me, as an avid luxury traveler. I've never had it, and never will. I value being able to turn our miles and points into international first class and business class award travel, such as Singapore Suites, Qantas First Class, Cathay Pacific First Class and similar flights--and the Capital One Venture card won't get you these flights.

Yet I often get asked about the Capital One Venture card by readers who notice its conspicuous absence on the Best Travel Rewards Credit Card page. For example, this recent comment, from a reader seeking advice on which card to apply for next:

"I'm looking for a new credit card for every day use but I don't travel regularly. I'd love for my rewards to be able to be used primarily for travel. Most of my spending is on groceries and dining out, along with your usual bills etc. I have been considering the AMEX Premier Rewards Gold card, which I currently have an offer for a 50k sign up bonus after spending 1k in 3 months. Also, I like the looks of the Capital One Venture card, which has a 40k pts sign up after 3k spend in the first 3 months and 2x spend on every purchase. First, is there a reason you don't mention the Capital One Venture card in your blog? Finally, after doing further research it looks like the Chase Sapphire Preferred is in consideration as well. Any guidance would be very much appreciated! Thank you!"

To give proper guidance, I'd want to better understand this reader's travel goals. But even if he mainly wants to travel domestically in economy rather than internationally in first class, I'd still recommend other cards before the Capital One Venture card.

Here are the 5 reasons I'll never bother with the Capital One Venture Rewards Card:

1. 3 Hard Credit Pulls: Lowers Your Credit Score More Than Applying for Other Credit Cards

If you apply for the Capital One Venture card, Capital One will initiate 3 hard pulls from Experian, Transunion and Equifax. Most credit card companies do just one hard pull--Chase typically pulls just Experian, Barclays typically pulls just Transunion, etc.

Each hard credit pull knocks a few points off your credit score, so by pulling from all three credit bureaus, Capital One does triple the damage to your credit score. Sure, your score will eventually recover, but why would you get a Capital One card when, as we'll see, there are so many more lucrative travel rewards cards you could get with just 1 hard credit pull?


2. There Are Bigger Credit Card Signup Bonuses

The Capital One Venture Rewards card is currently offering 40,000 points, but as we'll see, Venture Rewards points are worth less than a number of other miles and points currencies, especially if your goal is international first class or business class award travel.

Nor is 40,000 points all that great as a signup bonus. Consider that non-AMEX cardholders or lapsed cardholders can get targeted for as much as 150,000 signup bonuses--see 150K AMEX Business Platinum Bonus Offer (Targeted). And last year, there was a 100K Citi Executive AAdvantage Card and a 70K Ink Plus Bonus Offer

Even among current offers, I would signup first for the 50K Citi Platinum Select offer, the 50K CitiBusiness AAdvantage card, 50K Ink Plus, 40K Chase Sapphire Preferred (45K if you earn the 5K from adding an authorized user), 50K British Airways Visa, 50K United MileagePlus Explorer Visa, 50K US Airways Mastercard, etc., all of which provide both a higher signup bonus and greater value than any Capital One card.


3. There Are Better Spend Bonuses Than 2X

I don't know about you, but I'm tired of seeing the Capital One ads "What's in Your Wallet?" Here's what's in my wallet, and as you can see, no Capital One card.

2X on all spend? I'd much rather have 5X on a good chunk of my spend, where each "X" is more valuable. That's what the Ink Plus and Chase Freedom provide:

Ink Plus: 5X on phone spend, cable and Internet spend, 5X on all Amazon, 5X on all Whole Foods spend, 5X on all Starbucks and other store spend via gift cards bought for 5X at Staples and other office supply stores

Chase Freedom: 5X on rotating categories such as groceries, gas, restaurants, up to $1500 per quarter. Make sure your spouse or travel partner also has the card so you get 5X on up to $3000 per quarter on the bonus categories.


4. Airline Miles and Transferable Points Are MUCH Better for First Class and Business Class Award Travel

Some people give up on frequent flyer miles because they say they can never use them. But if you can either plan far enough in advance or at least be flexible with dates and routings, you can get so much more value out of frequent flyer miles and out of points that can be transferred to airline frequent flyer programs, such as Chase Ultimate Rewards, AMEX Membership Rewards points and SPG points. 

That's because you can use, for example, 67,500 (135,000 roundtrip) AAdvantage miles to book yourself from the U.S. to Asia in Cathay Pacific First Class, or 57,375 Ultimate Rewards points transferred to Singapore KrisFlyer to book Singapore Suites (with closing doors, pajamas, pre-ordered lobster thermidor, etc.) between NYC and Frankfurt, Germany, or any one of a number of other redemptions that give you a nominal value per mile of anywhere between 6 and 14 or more cents per mile.

You'll never get that kind of return on any kind of cash back card, such as the Capital One Venture, which basically is 2% cash back. That means that for the Cathay First Class flight above, which often costs $23,000, you'd have to spend over 1 million on your Venture card to be able to earn enough Venture points to book that ticket. Instead, you could have signed up for a couple of Citi AAdvantage cards when there was the 100K Citi Executive AAdvantage offer, or two 50K cards currently, and spend or transfer SPG points to earn the additional AAdvantage miles to book a Cathay award. 


5. There Are Better "Travel Cash Back" Cards

Even if you do want a cash back card, depending on your spend, you could easily be better off with the Chase Freedom, with no annual fee and rotating 5X cash back categories (plus, if you have the Ink Plus or Sapphire Preferred you can transfer those points to airlines instead of taking it as cash back) or the Barclays Arrival Plus World MasterCard, which has a similar 40K bonus and gives you an effective 2.2% cash back when redeemed on travel, due to its 10% rebate when you redeem your points on travel.

Do you find the Capital One Venture Card Worth It or Not?

Related posts

Capital One 100K Bonus Miles Mortgage Offer: How to Do Much Better

Understand How Your Credit Score Works to Maximize Credit Card Rewards

How We Earned 1 Million Miles and Points This Year

Best Luxury Hotels of 2014: Top 10 Most Popular TravelSort Hotels

Need Award Booking Help? Our fee is as low as $75 per ticket if you book your hotel through us.

If you enjoyed this, join 150,000+ readers: please follow TravelSort on Twitter or  like us on Facebook to be alerted to new posts. 

Become a TravelSort Client and Book Your Hotel with Virtuoso or Four Seasons Preferred VIP Amenities!

  • |
  • Print
    print |
Related Articles
User_avatar_default Raymond P. commented 07 Jan 2015
I got approved from Capital One Spark Business with $500 cash bonus after $4500 spend in 3 months and earn 1.5% cash back on everything. No annual fee.
Picture?type=large Gens L. commented 21 Aug 2016
Absolutely the CapOne Venture is the best card out there! Sure you can get better sign-up bonuses and 5x here and there (chase freedom), but what about when you just put a lot of spend on credit cards but don't need to hit any minimal spends currently? I don't need biz class tickets. What I need is travel cash (airline fees, hotels, Air BnBs, trains, Ubers, car rentals, tour buses, etc.) There are so many travel costs, and I don't need more airline miles (dime-a-dozen), but Travel Cash. Some make the argument of Barclay Arrival, which is a great card, but they never waive the annual fee ($89), but CapOne has ever year ($59). My wife and I went 8 nights to Portugal & Spain, earlier this year, and thanks to Amex MR Points (flying Air France) our built up spend on CapOne covered most of the trip, except food, etc. All-in cost for both of us ended up only being $475 total.
Avatar_60_hilary Hilary Stockton commented 21 Aug 2016
Glad you're enjoying the card, but for me personally the Capital One Venture card will never be worth it, when there are so many more attractive travel rewards cards. And among all of my many luxury travel clients, none of them have their Capital One Venture card as the travel credit card they choose to put their travel spend on--to them and to me, other miles and points are far more valuable. First class and business class awards are the highest value use of frequent flyer miles and points, since it's possible to redeem for 10 cents or more per mile or point depending on the redemption. With Venture points you're limited to a 2% return, one fifth or less the return of using miles and points for first class.
Picture?type=large Jonathan M. commented 23 Sep 2016
I depends where you assign value. Technically, the plane ride costs the same amount for every single person on the plane as a function of use and fuel. They are changing a premium for better seats - of which you think you are getting a better deal because they allow more redemption per mile. They are in fact setting the market on both sides of the transaction - for initial prices and miles redemption. I would never use a credit card via miles to move into first class as I would rather have a whole other trip in coach. Don't use credit card points to get into first class as you will pay a premium either way. The system is generally made for heavily travels that have status and tons of points outside of credit cards because travel so much. Using credit card points for upgrades isn't mathematically sound in the long run no matter how you slice it. Look at the total aggregate opportunity cost premium - typically the net emotional gain for first clas isn't worth the actual financial cost in real terms when the large majority of flights are domestic for 3 hours or less (from Dallas). End game - you will go more places year over year for less money with the CapOne according to math, statistics, and typical flight.
Avatar_60_hilary Hilary Stockton commented 23 Sep 2016
I think you're on the wrong site. This is a luxury travel site, and I virtually never book clients in economy class for international travel. They either use their miles and points and my award booking service to fly business or first class, or they pay to fly business or first class. So given the chance to use a couple credit card sign ups and/or spend (much of it at 5X with the Ink Plus or Chase Freedom or 3X with the 100K Chase Sapphire Reserve) it's a no brainer to use miles and points at a redemption rate of 5-10 or more cents per mile or point, vs. a straight 2 cents per dollar spent with the Capital One Venture. The goal for my clients is comfort, sleep quality, work productivity and overall enjoyment, and there's a reason why not a single one of them has a Capital One Venture card on file with me as their primary card. It has limited to no value for the luxury traveler.
Leave a Comment
Rewards Credit Cards
Get Free Email Blog Updates
Popular Articles
  The top travel credit cards can come with high annual fees, which is why it's a good idea to have an exit strategy for cards that don't justify their benefits after you've earned the signup bonus. Here are three...
  Earn 3X JetBlue TrueBlue Points at Amazon with your unique JetBlue link. While this offer has been around since last year, I missed posting about it, so better late than never. The great thing is that you can stack...
  JetBlue is by far my top choice if flying Economy in the U.S., and this was reconfirmed during a quick recent trip. We don't fly much domestically or in economy, but the times I've flown economy on legacy carriers...
  Activate Chase Freedom 5X for Grocery Stores and Drugstores, for April to June 2017 spend. Grocery stores are my favorite category, since even as a family of 3, we probably spend ~$150 per week on groceries, given that we...
  Which Chase credit cards should you downgrade to with no annual fees? TravelSort reader Eri writes: "Your recent post with regards to rethinking keeping the AMEX Business Platinum made me wonder what would be better options for Chase Ultimate Rewards...