Review: American First Class A321 San Francisco to New York

Review: American First Class A321 San Francisco to New York


This Review of American First Class on the A321 (32B) Transcon from SFO to New York JFK is one of several AA A321 reviews. For others, see my husband's American A321 First Class Review JFK to LAX and my prior American A321 First Class San Francisco to New York JFK Review.

Since our prior reviews covered American's A321 First Class Cabin and Seat Selection, I'll just quickly summarize the cabin and seat.

American A321 (32B) First Class Cabin and First Class Seat

American's A321 transcontinental first class cabin has 10 first class seats in a 1-1 configuration with seats angled toward the window, which is great since each seat has both a window and direct aisle access. As usual, I'd avoid the first row, row 1, and the last row, row 5, to minimize light and noise disturbance from the galley and lavatories.

Review-American First Class A321 Transcon


Each first class seat is 21 inches wide, so about a couple inches wider than business class, and is supposed to recline to a fully flat bed, although the lower part where your legs and feet are actually slopes downward slightly and isn't perfectly flat–more on this below.

Review: American First Class Seat 2F, A321 (32B)


The manual seat controls are easy to use, and are located by the in-flight entertainment controls.

American A321 (32B) Seat Controls


It's also easy to find the power outlet, which is in the small storage compartment where there's Dasani bottled water and a Cole Haan amenity kit with CO Bigelow lime and coriander body lotion and lip balm, along with a dental kit, sleep mask, socks, tissues, and ballpoint pen. Unfortunately no slippers are provided, however.

Cole Haan Amenity Kit, American First Class A321 Transcon


There's an additional storage compartment by the floor, good for putting your shoes in:

Storage for Small Items, American First Class A321 Review


American A321 (32B) First Class Menu and Food

Before we pushed back we were offered a pre-flight drink, and as usual I had some water.

Pre-Flight Drink, American First Class A321 Review


This was a red eye flight, so honestly I wasn't expecting much in the way of food. But to my surprise there was a menu and it even featured menu selections designed by celebrity chef and fellow Hawaiian Sam Choy, known for his creative Pacific Rim and Hawaii regional cuisine. I didn't want to miss out on trying something from the menu, so I ditched my plan to sleep for the entire flight.

Menu, American First Class A321 - Sam Choy



After take off, we were offered a mini hot towel (don't expect full size towels on American transcon flights):

Hot Towel, American First Class A321 Review


We were then offered another drink, along with mixed nuts. Unlike most of my prior United BusinessFirst flights, the mixed nuts were room temperature, not warmed up.

Mixed Nuts, American First Class A321 Review


The meal on this red eye flight was easily the best I've had on any U.S. domestic flight. Sure, you can say that it's hard to go wrong with fresh burrata cheese, but I still give credit to AA for collaborating with Sam Choy and for putting burrata cheese on the menu.

Dinner, American First Class A321 Review Red Eye Flight SFO-NYC


And the Pan Seared Crab Cakes with jicama slaw and tomatillo poblano cream sauce were fantastic–I would happily return to any restaurant serving these. I've no idea how the other entrees, the Thai Beef Salad and Vegetarian Cremini Bolgnese were, but if you like crab cakes and see these on your AA flight, order them.

Seared Crab Cakes, American First Class A321 Review


Dessert was Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia ice cream, not a sundae, but that makes perfect sense to me on a night flight when most want to get some sleep anyway and not wait for sundaes to be served.


American Airlines In-Flight Entertainment and First Class Headphones

American provides Bose noise cancelling headphones in first class, and the IFE is of course the same in all classes of service.

Bose Noise Cancelling Headphones, American First Class A321 Review


I watched the trailer for a History of Violence, with Viggo Mortensen, but knew I wouldn't be able to stomach many of the scenes of the full film.

A History of Violence, Viggo Mortensen, American A321 First Class


What I dislike is that AA forces you to return your headphones about 30-45 minutes before the flight ends, which is exactly when, on a red eye flight, you'd want to watch since you have to return your seat to its upright position for landing. While it's undoubtedly easier for AA to have all the headphones collected to minimize what crew have to do once the flight lands, I do think they should try to make an exception at least for first class, since it's only 10 seats.


American A321 (32B) First Class Bed and Sleep Quality

As our prior reviews have pointed out, American's A321 first class seat is mostly flat, but the lower section of it, which meets up with the shelf under the IFE to form the foot of the bed, is actually slightly angled, so it's not as perfectly flat as AA's Business Class seat on the same A321. This may or may not bother you, but it's worth being aware of. I always find airline beds too firm (except for Singapore Suites and JAL First Class and Business Class) so I used the duvet as a kind of mattress pad. Even with a sleep aid I only got a couple hours of sleep, but that's certainly better than nothing, and even being able to rest on a flat bed is very welcome on a red eye flight.

Flat Bed, American First Class A321 SFO-NYC Review


The Verdict

It's not surprising that American, with its 2016 Award Chart Devaluation, increased the miles required for its A321 (32B) transcon flights vs. the old recliner first class, and also sharply reduced the saver award space. The products are so different from each other they might as well be different airlines. In particular I was impressed with the meal quality on this red eye flight, due to the Sam Choy burrata appetizer and seared crab cakes main dish. As fantastic as this was, however, I'm unlikely to pay for this product unless it's similarly priced to JetBlue Mint, which in my experience is always less expensive, at least when purchased well in advance.

If you've flown American A321 transcon in first class recently, what was your experience?

Related Posts

Review: American A321 Business Class New York to Los Angeles

Review: American Airlines Old A321 First Class with Recliner Seats

Buy AAdvantage Miles with 100K Bonus? Not Worth It for Most

Review: American Airlines A321 First Class San Francisco to New York JFK

Need Award Booking Help? Our fee is as low as $75 per ticket if you book your hotel or cruise with us.

If you enjoyed this, join 200,000+ readers: please follow TravelSort on Twitter or  like us on Facebook to be alerted to new posts. 

Become a TravelSort Client and Book Your Luxury Hotel with Virtuoso or Four Seasons Preferred Partner Benefits!

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Share This:
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments