Persistence Pays Off for AAdvantage Awards
Rewards Credit Cards
Hilary Stockton

My Award Booking Service helps travelers book first class and business class with miles and points. As an independent affiliate of Cadence, I also have access to Four Seasons Preferred Partner, VirtuosoPeninsula Hotels PenClub, Dorchester Diamond Club, Belmond Bellini Club, Shangri-La Luxury Circle, Langham CoutureRitz-Carlton STARS, Starwood Luxury Privileges, Rocco Forte and other 5-star hotel partners, so I can book, for no extra cost, your perfect luxury hotel or luxury cruise with VIP amenities not available anywhere else. Become a client and upgrade your stay!

Have a travel question we haven't covered yet? Want to share your secrets for traveling well for less?

Persistence Pays Off for AAdvantage Awards


Persistence often pays off, including for award tickets. I book many AAdvantage awards for Award Booking clients, because even though Alaska miles are often less expensive, have the advantage of allowing a stopover on a one way award, and are less expensive to redeposit if you change your mind (you only pay the $25 partner award booking fee if you cancel over 60 days before departure), many of my clients have AAdvantage miles, not Alaska miles.

Many times my call to the AAdvantage partner award desk goes without a hitch. Today, however, I needed to change a client's Cathay Pacific Business Class return date so that he'd be back in time for a family member's high school graduation, as the school had changed the graduation ceremony date. Although it's a few months away, there was no Cathay Pacific Business Class award availability for his preferred date, or even for the 4 days prior to his preferred date, either with AAdvantage miles or even with Cathay Pacific Asia Miles.

Checking British Airways Executive Club and Qantas Frequent Flyer I could see a single Cathay Pacific First Class award, so I called AAdvantage to book it:

Me: "Hello, I'm hoping you can help me change a client's return ticket to another date, may I give you the record locator?"

AAdvantage Agent: "Sure, please go ahead."

Me: "It's [record locator] for [client name] flying Cathay [flight number] in Business Class on [date]. We'd like to change it to [new date]. Could you please check if you can see 1 Cathay First Class award seat available?"

AAdvantage Agent: "Let me check that for you...[pause]...there are only economy awards for that date."

Me: "Hmm, that's strange. Could you please check the dates prior to it?" [These were dates that were also showing a first class award seat, both in British Airways and Qantas, as well as Cathay Asia Miles]

AAdvantage Agent: "There are only Economy awards for those dates as well. There are no First Class or Business Class awards seats for any of those dates."

Me: "Just to double check, it's Cathay Pacific [flight number] departing Hong Kong on [date] at [time] and arriving at JFK at [time]. There's no first class award seat?"

AAdvantage Agent: "No, there's no availability in business or first class for that date."

Me: "Ok, thanks for your help."

After I ended that call, I called back, and fortunately got a different agent. She was able to see the space without any problems, so after asking her to grab the space, I proceeded to top up my client's account, since my client was short a few thousand AAdvantage miles.

That said, she said the award would be redeposited for a fee of $150 before being rebooked. AAdvantage typically does NOT charge when changing to a higher class of service, although you do pay the redeposit fee when moving to a lower class of service. So I asked politely about this, mentioning, which was true, that I'd switched a client to a higher class of service just a few days ago, and there's been no redeposit fee, only the difference in miles and taxes. It would be great, I mentioned, if she could check if the redeposit fee could be waived this time as well.

She said she'd check with her Support Desk, and after she had, she said that they'd waive the fee, which is what I'd expected, although of course I thanked her. It makes no sense to give agents the sense that you're trying to tell them how to do their job, if you hope to get the results you want.

Finally my client's ticket was queued for ticketing (AAdvantage awards don't ticket automatically and are queued), so it was time for me to select a Cathay Pacific First Class seat. The online system didn't permit a seat assignment, probably because it hadn't finished ticketing yet, but I was able to call Cathay Pacific (I find the Hong Kong line is answered faster, although even so I was on hold about 10 min.) and assign seat 1A (also see Best Seats in Cathay Pacific First Class?)

Bottom Line

I'm not sure why the first agent didn't see the award space, since typically British Airways Executive Club and Qantas Frequent Flyer Cathay Pacific award space matches what AAdvantage and Alaska Mileage Plan can book. It is true that Cathay Pacific Asia Miles can have better award availability for Asia Miles bookings, however, so you can't exclusively use Asia Miles award availability to check space when wanting to book using partner miles. In any case, it pays to HUCA if you at first get the answer that there's no Cathay award space on multiple days when you've found Cathay space with both British Airways and Qantas and/or JAL. Similarly, you shouldn't have to pay the $150 redeposit fee for AAdvantage if you're switching to a higher class of service for the award ticket and only changing the date (as long as over 21 days from departure), not the route, origin or destination.

Has persistence paid off for you when booking award tickets?

Recommended Posts

Cathay Pacific First Class Review, Hong Kong to LAX

Review: Cathay Pacific The Pier First Class Lounge, Hong Kong Airport

Review: Cathay Pacific's Renovated The Pier Business Class Lounge, Hong Kong

Review: Cathay Pacific The Wing First Class Lounge, Hong Kong Airport

Cathay Pacific First Class: Don't Count On All Unsold Seats Released as Awards

Need Award Booking Help? Our fee is as low as $75 per ticket if you book your hotel through us.

If you enjoyed this, join 200,000+ readers: please follow TravelSort on Twitter or  like us on Facebook to be alerted to new posts. 

Become a TravelSort Client and Book Luxury Hotels with Virtuoso or Four Seasons Preferred Partner Benefits! 

  • |
  • Print
    print |
Related Articles
User_avatar_default David C. commented 13 Mar 2017
Thanks for sharing the story, which echoes very well with my experience. The key, as you said, is always be polite and if the process doesn't go through as I expect, politely HUCA. Only one minor question in the story: how do you real-time top-off an AA account? I can easily top off UA in real-time (from Chase UR) but not AA (from SPG takes days...). Thanks
Avatar_60_hilary Hilary Stockton commented 14 Mar 2017
David, I should have clarified, but by topping up I meant buying the needed AAdvantage miles, since purchases go through instantly. As you point out, there's unfortunately no points currency that transfers instantly to AAdvantage, which is why we are quite focused at the moment on rebuilding our AAdvantage miles balances.
User_avatar_default David C. commented 14 Mar 2017
I see. I thought you have some magic that you kept only for your booking service. :-) Thanks again for sharing.
Picture?type=large Peter W. commented 17 Mar 2017
Just arrived back in SF from a 2.5 week trip to Asia. I got seat 1A on both the outbound and inbound flights. (SFO-HKG and HKG-SFO). It was my first time flying CX First Class. The experience on the outbound flight was mediocre and I was not impressed. Thankfully the crew on my flight a few hours ago was exceptional and I really enjoyed the flight. While private, I agree with you that Seat 1 A is less private than Seat 2A. I have found my flights on CX to be either very good or mediocre about 50% of the time. I have found SQ to be more consistent. Of course the bottom line is which airline has an award seat that is available.
Leave a Comment
Hotel Rewards Credit Cards
Get Free Email Blog Updates
Popular Articles
  This ANA First Class 777 Review for a New York JFK to Tokyo Narita flight is part of a new trip report including Tokyo luxury hotels, restaurants and sushi bars. Having previously enjoyed JAL First Class, we were looking...
  This British Airways First Class 747 Review is one of my several reviews of British Airways First Class; see all posts tagged British Airways, or for other airline first class and business class reviews, see my Airline Reviews. Since...
  This Japan Airlines (JAL) 777-300ER Business Class Sky Suite Review is from our recent trip to Japan, including ANA First Class, JAL Business Class review, and Tokyo luxury hotel reviews and Kyoto luxury hotel reviews. For previous posts in...
  Persistence often pays off, including for award tickets. I book many AAdvantage awards for Award Booking clients, because even though Alaska miles are often less expensive, have the advantage of allowing a stopover on a one way award, and...
Can you transfer AAdvantage miles into AMEX Membership Rewards points or Chase Ultimate Rewards points? Reader Michael writes "I have a lot of American Airlines miles from a Citi AAdvantage card, is there a way to transfer those points to...
  The AMEX Business Platinum will add new benefits, 5X points on flights and prepaid hotels booked with AMEX Travel, effective March 30, 2017, per Flyertalk. This is better news than for the personal AMEX Platinum, which will raise its...
  It's possible to buy AMEX Membership Rewards points, in conjunction with a points transfer. This post will discuss how to buy Membership Rewards points, how much it costs, whom you can transfer points to, and when it's likely to...
I'm rethinking my AMEX Business Platinum. While I'd assumed I was going to cancel it later this year, after collecting the $200 in airline incidental credit, I'm sure now that I'll keep it at least another year. Why? It's well...
  AMEX Platinum's fee is increasing to $550 effective March 30, 2017, and some new "benefits" are being added, such as monthly $15 Uber credits and 5X on prepaid hotels booked with AMEX. Meh. While I don't have the AMEX...
  This Review of the Air France Lounge New York JFK is from a 2017 visit prior to a JAL Business Class flight from New York to Tokyo Narita. See all of our airport lounge reviews, or, if you are flying Japan...